The Board
Every cigar, ranked.
All 21 cigars we've scored, best to worst. Every number comes from a full long-form review — specs, tasting notes by thirds, pairing, burn and draw — and no score has ever been for sale. Click any cigar for the complete written review.
The Regular
91–95“Something I have regularly in the humidor”
1Principal Cigars putting the principal cigars 1842 lancero to the testSan Andres · Medium-Full952Stolen Throne putting the castle 919 by stolen thrones to the testHabano · Medium-Full933Dunbarton Cigars Putting the Red Meat Lovers Porterhouse To The testConnecticut Broadleaf · Full934Diaz Cabrerra Putting The Eladio Diaz B&A To The TestCorojo · Medium935Henry Clay Putting Henry Clays "War Hawk" To The TestConnecticut Shade · Medium-Full936Definition Cigars The Definition Cigars The Walking StickMaduro · Full937Definition Cigars Smoking 2 Cigars At Once? The Definition Cigars The Walking Stick & The DC KinsmanSan Andres · Medium-Full938My Father Trying The My Father La LealtadEcuador Connecticut · Medium-Full929Ritual Cigars Testing Out The Ritual Cigars Virrey - IntrigantePeruvian Puro · Medium-Full9210Espinosa Putting The Espinosa Sumatra To The TestSumatra · Medium9111Espinosa Putting The Espinosa La Bomba Warhead 12 To The TestConnecticut Broadleaf · Medium91
The Reach
86–90“Reach-for-it on a good evening”
12Karen Berger Putting Karen Bergers Halftime To The testHabano · Medium-Full9013Luciano Cigars Putting The Maria Lucia By Luciano Cigars To The TestConnecticut Broadleaf · Medium-Full9014Ritual Cigars Putting The Virrey Paderoso To The TestSumatra · Medium-Full8915Aganorsa Leaf Putting The Aganorsa Leaf Aniversaro Grand Toro To The TestCorojo · Medium-Full8816Cohiba Putting The Cohiba Short Story To The TestCorojo · Medium-Full8717Casa Carillo Putting The Casa Carrillo Deep Blue To The TestHabano · Medium-Full8718AJ Fernandez Putting The AJ Fernandez Sunrise To The TestEcuador Connecticut · Medium8719Ritual Cigars Ritual Cigars Conquistador MaduroMaduro · Medium-Full86
The Backup
81–85“If there's nothing else, I'd happily smoke it”
The Pass
71–80“I wouldn't pick this up again”
Scores are assigned at review time and don't move afterward. New reviews land twice a month — subscribe to catch them, or suggest a cigar for the board.